Expert Reviews | Authors | Book Talk

Darkly Dreaming Dexter, by first time author Jeff Lindsay is a book about a serial killer, Dexter Morgan. Dexter is not your typical serial killer; he's a killer with a conscience. He only kills those who deserve to die: other serial killers. Dexter's day job is with the Miami police force where he works as a blood spatter analyst. The story takes a turn when a copycat killer shows up and leaves dismembered limbs of innocent Miami victims as mocking clues for the police and ultimately for Dexter as if saying "catch me if you can".

Back to booklist
Buy this book

See how many daggers our experts gave Darkly Dreaming Dexter. Dagger ratings are from 0 to 5, with 5 daggers being the best.

  < More expert reviews for this book

Janice MacDonald
Crime Writer
Read bio


Curtis Rind
Police Officer
Read bio

Mystery readers get pretty savvy pretty quickly. There's a formula inherent in the mystery - you know there will be a crime, there will be a killer, there will be a detective pursuing the killer, there will be an answer to the crime. So you look for the details. You look for the character, the setting, or the profession for an insider's look. In a straight mystery novel what you've really got is a morality tale.

I had a problem with this book right off the bat. I know that at a crime scene the police always hold back some bit of evidence because there are innocent people who will confess to murders. We get someone arrested for these murders very quickly - one that Dexter and his sister know isn't the killer, but nobody seems to think this is bad.

I wanted to love this book because I actually am quite fond of literary monsters. But I don't buy Dexter. He doesn't work as a sociopath at all. The guy's a kosher killer. He wants to exsanguinate his people so that there's no blood. Blood makes him nauseous, so the ultimate kill would be the bloodless kill, and yet he never gets anywhere on that. Any detail he gives us shows that he's going to have to shower from head to toe - he's vivisecting people! There's a sense of "How did you think that was going to work, Dexter?"

Other reviews by Janice MacDonald:
The Maltese Falcon
Memory Book
The Torment of Others


The things that I found compelling about this book were Dexter's view of the world, his relationship with his father, and how he's come to be the person that he is. Dexter's inner monologue was what really drew me into the killings. You can feel his pulse racing, you get a sense of his excitement. Where the author really lost it was with the introduction of the media and the press to the crime scenes. That's so far out in left field it's not even funny.

As far as the policing aspect of this book, there were some things that were greatly sensationalized, but the dialogue and banter between the colleagues was pretty true to form. Although, in nine years I have never seen people blow up at each other as regularly as they do in this book's police environment.

Dexter would make a fabulous, entertaining movie, but I wouldn't pick up the sequel. I waddled my way through this book, pleasantly entertained, but I need a little bit more meat.

Other reviews by Curtis Rind:
Strange Affair